Parchment vs. Silicone Mats: What I Use After 15 Years

Quick answer: Both work well, but it comes down to how often you bake. Parchment paper wins for convenience, disposability, and crisp-bottomed bakes. Silicone mats win for frequent bakers, sticky sugar work, and cutting long-term cost and waste. After 15 years I now reach for parchment on about 90% of my bakes and save silicone mats for macarons. Here’s the full breakdown 👇

Baking enthusiasts know that the right tools can make all the difference in achieving perfectly baked goods. Two of the most commonly used tools for lining baking sheets are parchment paper and silicone baking mats. (We’ll talk about Teflon at a later time….) But which one is right for you? In this guide, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both, the types of baking they’re suited for, and how to make the most out of your baking setup.

Having been a baker for almost 15 years (!!!) – I was a silicone mats girl through and through until recently. When I moved across the country, I re-purchased a lot of my old supplies and realized that my previously favorite silicone mats are now lower quality, thinner and stickier, making them kind of a nightmare to work with. I used this opportunity to give parchment another go, and for everything except macarons, I’m now baking on parchment with a pizza stone on the bottom rack for 90% of my baked goods. My personal reasons are:

• Ease: I’m not cleaning my mats after each bake anymore
• Cleanliness: Since it’s one time use, it’s one and done
• Maintenance: None with parchment. With silicone mats, the main thing is keeping them away from anything furry (especially pesky clothing fibers), because they are so sticky! Dust also stick to them like crazy. I’m always cleaning them.
• Consistency: Unless if you’re using all the same brand of silicone mats for all your bakes, each brand varies heavily between thickness and performance. You need to learn how each behaves and the difference in heat transfer can be huge! Parchment seems more predictable overall, there tends to be less variance in thickness and performance,
• Aesthetics: The bottoms of your bakes will look different between parchment and silicone- this is very personal and up to you! Some people insist on getting a perfect grid look, I’m not one of those people, but you do you 😉

HOWEVER, I still prefer to use mats for macarons, and it’s primarily aesthetic – they bake up fine (might have to adjust since parchment conducts heat differently than silicone mats), but they don’t keep their round shape as much without securing the corners of the parchment down with a dab of batter ‘glue’- and I don’t want to stain my pans like that… call me vain lol. I also find macarons easier to remove from silicone over parchment.

What Is Parchment Paper?

Parchment paper is a thin, disposable, non-stick paper that’s coated with silicone or quilon to make it resistant to moisture and grease. It’s available in pre-cut sheets or rolls, making it versatile for lining baking trays, wrapping food, or even piping if you roll it into a cone. NOT to be confused with WAX PAPER, which we do not use for baking as the wax will melt and stick to your baked goods!

Pros of Parchment Paper:

1. Non-Stick Surface: Prevents cookies, pastries, and other baked goods from sticking to the pan.
2. Easy Cleanup: Disposable, so you can just toss it when you’re done baking.
3. Versatile: Can be cut to any size and used for more than just baking—like roasting veggies or cooking en papillote (wrapped cooking).
4. Heat Resistant: Handles temperatures up to 450°F (check your brand’s limits).

Cons of Parchment Paper:

1. Not Reusable: Single-use, which may not be ideal for eco-conscious bakers.
2. Can Burn: At very high temperatures, parchment paper may brown or scorch – I avoid using it for things like pizza dough where the oven is at 450 degrees F+

There are LOTS of parchment paper options and each brand will talk about what makes theirs unique. Generally, there are sheets and rolls, and I prefer the sheets for ease. I look for a balance between quality and quantity, and usually find that $17-$20 for 200 sheets is a decent price.

What Is a Silicone Baking Mat?

A silicone baking mat is a reusable, non-stick baking liner made from food-grade silicone and fiberglass. These mats are durable, easy to clean, and designed to last for years.

Pros of Silicone Baking Mats:

1. Eco-Friendly: Reusable, reducing waste in your kitchen.
2. Non-Stick Surface: Excellent for sticky doughs, caramel, or sugar work.
3. Even Heat Distribution: Helps cookies and baked goods bake more evenly.
4. Durable: Can last for years with proper care, making it a cost-effective investment.

Cons of Silicone Baking Mats:

1. Upfront Cost: More expensive than parchment paper initially.
2. Size Limitations: Mats come in specific sizes and can’t be easily cut to fit irregular pans. In fact, DO NOT cut silicone mats as many of them have these glass microfibers in them that, if cut and ingested, could cause major health issues.
3. Storage/Cleaning: Can take up more space if not rolled or stored flat. Keep them somewhere away from debris as everything sticks to them.

Parchment Paper vs. Silicone Baking Mats: When to Use Each

• For General Baking: Both work well! If you bake often, silicone mats are cost-effective LONG TERM. Parchment paper may be more convenient, but also might not be the best for things like macarons– it really takes a lot of experimenting.
• For Roasting: Parchment paper makes cleanup a breeze when roasting vegetables or proteins.
• For Candy and Sugar Work: Silicone baking mats are better suited for high-heat sugar work, thanks to their durability.

The Baking Sheets I Swear By: Nordic Ware Aluminum Sheets

The foundation of a great bake starts with the right baking sheets. Nordic Ware aluminum baking sheets are my go-to for their durability, even heat distribution, and quality craftsmanship. Unlike non-stick sheets that can wear out over time, Nordic Ware sheets provide consistent results and last for years. You can also purchase their “natural” line HERE.

Why I Love Nordic Ware:

1. Even Heat Distribution: Helps prevent burnt edges and underbaked centers.
2. Lightweight and Durable: Made from high-quality aluminum that resists warping.
3. Versatile: Perfect for cookies, sheet cakes, roasting veggies, and more.

If you’re on a budget, THESE are a good price and I actually owned a couple before making my big move across the country

Final Thoughts: Which Is Best for You?

The choice between parchment paper and silicone baking mats ultimately depends on your baking habits and preferences. If you’re an occasional baker or prefer disposable convenience, parchment paper is a great option. If you bake frequently or want to invest in an eco-friendly alternative, silicone baking mats are the way to go.

There’s no WRONG answer here- I recommend trying a couple to see what you prefer. We all work with different recipes, equipment, in different environments – so experiment and see what works for you!

FAQ: Parchment Paper vs. Silicone Baking Mats

Are silicone baking mats safe? Yes. Quality mats are made from food-grade silicone reinforced with fiberglass and are safe up to around 480–500°F. The one rule: never cut a silicone mat — the glass microfibers inside can be harmful if they end up in food.

What temperature can parchment paper vs. silicone mats handle? Parchment is generally rated to about 450°F (it can scorch above that), while silicone mats typically handle 480–500°F. Always check your specific brand’s limit — I avoid parchment for anything 450°F+ like pizza.

Can you reuse parchment paper? Yes, a few times — as long as it isn’t scorched and you stay under its heat limit. But it’s designed as single-use, so it won’t last like a silicone mat.

Which is better for cookies? Parchment tends to give crisper edges and bottoms because it lets more moisture escape. Silicone gives more even, gentler bottoms. Pick based on the cookie texture you’re after.

Which is better for macarons? I prefer silicone for macarons — better shape retention and easier release. Parchment works too, but you may need to adjust (it conducts heat differently) and anchor the corners so it doesn’t curl.

4) ADD THIS FUNNEL BLOCK — after “Final Thoughts”

(Hobby/general-baking intent = SOFT funnel. Your affiliate links already do the product work; add the free-tools hook + email capture. No hard MCB pitch here — wrong audience mindset.)

Free tools for bakers: Want to take the guesswork out of the rest of your baking? I built a set of free calculators and planners over at My Custom Bakes Baker Tools — free to use, no catch.